When Jessa and Lou meet under slightly mortifying circumstances involving a fourteen-foot shark in Hawaii, they are both clear on what they want for Christmas.

Jessa's wishlist:
Surfboards
Mai Tais
That really big bonus at work

Lou's wishlist:
Cheesy Christmas movies
A date to his brother's wedding
Jessa

Can Lou convince Jessa to give Christmas–and him–a try? Or is she better off protecting her little chestnut of a heart?